Islam is not only a religion in the ordinary sense of the word, but a complete system
of life. While other religious codes provide guidance only for the relation between
man and his Creator, Islam guides man in his relationship with God, and gives him
the norms which govern his temporal existence, since Islam is concerned with the
spiritual, political, social economic, moral and all other material aspects of the
human being.
Every social system has its own economic system. Islam being a comprehensive and
distinct social system, possesses a corresponding economic system of its own. Islamic
economics is fast developing into a different and distinct paradigm of economics.
Therefore, a number of Islamic financial institutions have emerged in various Muslim
as well as some non-Muslim countries.
Difference between Islamic and conventional banks
There are a number of key differences between the products and services offered
by a conventional bank in comparison to an Islamic financial institution.
Firstly, Islam is the back bone of interest free banking, moral principles and objectives
play a more important role in its operations. As such it is organized on the basis
of cooperation with each other as stated in the Quranic injuction: "Help you one
another in righteousness and piety but help you not one another in sin and trasgression"
(Quran, 5:2). The Quran also calls for trade "Eat not up your property among yourselves
in vanities but let there be amongst you, traffic by mutual goodwill"(Quran, 4:29).
Honesty and trustworthiness is so essential in business, thus the Prophet (Pbuh)
had declared that dishonest transactions are illegal (reported by Bukhari).
Secondly, no gain is accepted without either effort or liability. Islam forbids
receiving a monetary advantage without giving a counter value, but is not opposed
to profit or financial gain as long as an effort is performed or (partial) liability
is accepted for the financial result of a venture.
Thirdly, general conditions of a debtor should be evaluated genuinely. If one is
in financial distress, and is not able to pay back the principal, one should be
given an extension on humanitarian ground without any penalty. (Quran, 2:280)
Fourthly, certain business transactions are considered unlawful in Islam and cannot
be carried out in an Islamic bank. For example trading in alcohol, intoxicating
drugs, gambling or producing pornography are contrary to Islam.
Fifthly, Islamic banks offer no interest-bearing products or services, and in its
organisational structure and corporate governance, Islamic banks have Shariah board,
to ensure that the bank practices are in conformity with the Shariah and do not
oppress the disadvantaged client.
Prohibition of Riba in the Quran and Sunnah
What is Riba?
It is the addition of premium paid to the lender in return for the waiting period
as a condition for the loan. Riba has the same meaning and import as interest in
accordance with the consensus of all fuqaha (jurists) and is haram. The following
are the steps on Riba prohibition:
First stage of prohibition of Riba
Says God: "That which you give as interest to increase the peoples wealth increases
not with God; but that which you give in charity, seeking the pleasure of God, multiplies
manifold". (Quran, 30:39)
Second stage of prohibition
Say God: "For the wrong doing of Jews, we made unlawful for them certain good
foods which had been lawful for them - and for their hindering many from God's way.
And their taking of Riba"(usury) though they were forbidden from taking it. (Quran,
4:160-161)
Third stage of prohibition
Says God: "O you who believe: Eat not Riba (usury) doubled and multiplied, and
fear God that you may be successful. (Quran, 3:130)
Fourth and final stage of prohibition
Says God: "O you who believe! Be conscious of Allah and give up what remains
(due to you) from Riba (usury) (from now onward), if you are (really) believers.
And if you do not do it, then take a notice of war from Allah and his Messenger,
but if you repent you shall have your capital sums. Deal not unjustly (by asking
more than your capital sums) and you shall not be dealt unjustly (by receiving less
than your capital sums).
Prohibition of Riba in the Sunnah
Reported by Jabir bin Abdullah that the Prophet (Pbuh) said: "Cursed is the
receiver and the payer of interest, the one who records it and the two witnesses
to the transaction". And he said: "They are all alike". (Muslim)
ISLAMIC BANKING IN PRACTICE
Islamic banks operate various types of transactions the most important of which
are:
I. Collection of Deposit
Since interest bearing deposits entail Riba, Islamic banks offer two different
kinds of deposits.
- Current account
- Investment account
Current account: The deposited capital is guaranteed and made available to the client
on demand. No reward is paid on the deposit but is mainly used for transactions
and safety keeping.
Investment account: Deposits remain with the bank for a certain previously agreed
period. Customers open investment account to yield financial return based on trust
financing. The depositor is the financing partner, while the managing partner is
the bank.
II. Financing contracts
1. Murabaha (mark-up sale)
It comes from the Arabic word 'ribh' which means profit (short –term trade financing).
Murabaha is selling a commodity as per the purchasing price with a defined and agreed
profit mark-up. This mark-up may be a percentage of the selling price or a lump
sum. Murabaha financing differs from a conventional financing, as it involves the
financing of physical assets. The bank shares in the risk of ownership. Rather than
simply advancing money to a client, the bank itself buys the goods from a third
party on request of a customer. The bank then sells it to the customer for a pre-agreed
price through a deferred payment scheme, usually in the form of installments.
2. Musharaka (profits and loss sharing system)
It is an agreement between two persons or more (bank and customer)sharing both
profits and losses. It is a joint enterprise where all the partners contribute capital
and the client bring in know how. Profit/losses are shared on agreed ratios.
Islamic bank vs Conventional bank
Conventional banks have fixed rate of returns; while Musharaka, base their returns
on the actual profits made. Conventional banks as opposed to Islamic ones do not
share losses nor do they take such risks. Conventional banks have no interest on
how the business is run; while in Musharaka the Islamic bank is directly involved
in the proper functioning of the business.
Types of Musharaka partnerships
There are many types of Musharaka ranging from traditional types of partnerships
to modern corporations. Musharaka could either be:
Permanent musharaka: An Islamic bank participates in the equity of a project and
receives a share of the profit on a prorata basis. The time length of the contract
is specified, making it suitable for financing projects where funds are committed
over a long period.
Diminishing musharaka: This allows equity participation and sharing of profits on
a prorata basis, and provides a method through which the bank keeps on reducing
its equity in the project, ultimately transferring ownership of the asset to the
customer. The contract provides for payment over and above the bank's share in the
profit for the equity held by the bank. Simultaneously the entrepreneur purchases
some of the banks equity, progressively reducing it until the bank has no equity
and thus ceases to be a partner.
3. Mudharaba
It is a partnership in profit whereby one party provides capital (rab al-maal-the
bank) and the other party provides the know how/labour (Mudharib). The bank contributes
100% of the capital. Profits are shared on an agreed ratio. If there is any loss
the bank takes 100% responsibility unless there was a case of misconduct, negligence
or breech of contract on the part of Mudharib.
4.Ijara contract (leasing) or Ijara Muntahia bi at-tamleek (lease ending in property
ownership
Ijara: Is the same as leasing thus leasing practised in interest – free banks
is similar to its conventional practice. During the life of the asset, the risk
of ownership remains with the bank, while the lessee is liable for misuse of the
asset.
Ijara Muntahia bi at-tamleek (lease ending in property ownership)
This is a form of leasing contract, which includes a promise by the lesser to transfer
the ownership of the leased property to the lessee. Example, the bank purchases
the asset say a house. The client rents it from the bank, as he enters into an agreement
to buy the shares from the bank over an agreed time frame. He then buys out small
shares from the bank from time to time ending up with 100% ownership.
5. Bay'us-Salam (Advance purchase)
Advance payment for goods which are to be delivered at a specified future date.
Under normal circumstances, a sale cannot be effected unless the goods are in existence
at the time of the bargain. However, this type of sale is an exception, provided
the goods are defined and the date of delivery is fixed. The objects of sale must
be tangible goods that can be defined as to the quantity, quality and workmanship.